ARTICLE
TITLE

Theoretical (Dis-) position and Strategic Leitmotivs in Constitutional Interpretation in South Africa

SUMMARY

This essay takes a look at the historic restoration that bequeathed this country and its people a prototypical, justiciable Constitution. The advent of constitutional democracy in South Africa went hand in hand with an about-turn in the interpretation of enacted law-texts (including the Constitution) and a critical interrogation of certain dominant beliefs about the interpretation of law in general and enacted law in particular. Hitherto mostly unnamed or unlabelled (but not entirely alien) interpretive strategies pursued and developed by users of the Constitution are discussed, concentrating mainly on the jurisprudence of the Constitutional Court. Central to the author's approach is an acknowledgement of the decisive actuality of an interpreter's theoretical position becoming visible through (interpretive) leitmotivs. These recur as keynote or defining ideas, motifs or topoi lending direction to specific instances of construing law. Four leitmotivs pertinent to certain constellations of events in constitutional interpretation are discussed and their applicability and utility assessed, drawing on examples from constitutional case-law. The leitmotivs are: (i) transitional constitutionalism; (ii) transformative constitutionalism; (iii) monumental constitutionalism; and (iv) memorial constitutionalism. (i) and (ii) belong together as (A) programmatic leitmotivs and (iii) and (iv) as (B) commemorative leitmotivs. The author concludes that, although scouting out and engaging with leitmotivs call for profound reading and for text analysis of a sort with which "logical" jurists are not always too comfortable, the said endeavours have the potential to be exceptionally rewarding.   

 Articles related

Delmo Mattos da SILVA,Tereza Cristina Soares da Fonseca CARVALHO    

Objetivo: Este artigo, inserido no âmbito da filosofia de Emmanuel Lévinas e do Paradigma Restaurativo na esfera do Direito Penal contemporâneo, busca circunscrever e discutir as possíveis aproximações entre a Ética da Alteridade e a Justiça Restaurativa... see more


  Iqrak Sulhin    

The enactment of Law Number 22 of 2022 concerning Corrections (Pemasyarakatan), which replaces the previous Law Number 12 of 1995, significantly changes the implementation of Correctional functions, mainly the functions carried out by Probation and Parol... see more


Adriana Isabelle Barbosa Lima Sá Leitão,Tarin Cristino Frota Mont'Alverne    

The outbreak of the Covid-19 pandemic brought a series of behavioural changes in society, such as the need for social distancing and the use of protective masks or latex gloves. The increasing consumption of these materials has raised a new alert about m... see more


Marcus Mauricius HOLANDA,Rogério da Silva e SOUZA,Jackeline Ribeiro e SOUSA    

Objetivo:  O meio ambiente é bem dignamente autônomo, todavia, a reflexão constitucional não delimita fundamentos positivos para a vivacidade ambiental plena, sobretudo porque lhe falta o posicionamento de estruturante como fundamento constitucional... see more


Tawny Raquel Gallegos-Alor,Antonio Carlos Wolkmer    

DOI: 10.1590/2179-8966/2020/50747 ResumenLa presente contribución reflexiva objetiva analiza la cuestión del género, sus relaciones de subalternidad y los impactos discriminadores generados por la colonialidad del poder, abriendo en un dado espacio ... see more