Home  /  Lexikos  /  Núm: Vol31 Par: 0 (2021)  /  Article
ARTICLE
TITLE

Problems in Defining Ethnicity Terms in Dictionaries

SUMMARY

Despite the fact that lexicographers have increasingly been taking more care when it comes to defining socially sensitive terms, we argue that ethnicity terms still remain rather poorly defined. In a number of online monolingual dictionaries we surveyed in this study, we find that ethnicity terms are generally simplistically defined, mostly in terms of geography and citizenship, and argue that such definitions are too reductionist and sometimes even erroneous. We also find that some disparaging ethnicity terms are not labelled as such in some of the dictionaries surveyed. We also present a case study from Montenegro, in which a dictionary of the national academy of sciences was immediately revoked over a few ethnicity and ethnicity-related terms, after a violent outcry from two of Montenegro's ethnic minorities, dissatisfied with how their ethnicities were defined and treated in the dictionary. Based on our survey and the earlier findings from the literature, we recommend that international dictionaries follow a standardised model of defining ethnicities, which would additionally refer to an ethnicity's culture and potentially language, and be as inclusive as possible. We also recommend that editors and lexicographers of national dictionaries pay special attention to how they define the ethnic terms relating to the minorities living in their country or region, following a combination of a standardised and a partly customised approach, which would take into account the specific features of the minorities.

 Articles related

Ruth Feil    

This paper gives an outline of a research project conceming Danish support verb constructions (German: Funktionsverbgefiige), a phenomenon previously confined to the periphery of Danish linguistics. The following issues are addressed: problems in definin... see more


Piet Swanepoel    

ABSTRACT: This article focuses on some of the problems raised by Atkins and Rundell's (2008) approach to the design of lexicographic definitions for members of lexical sets. The questions raised are how to define and identify lexi... see more

Revista: Lexikos

??????? ?. ??????? ????????    

The event is one of the unavoidable narratological categories for defining the minimum conditions of story. Beginning with Aristotle, structuralist, semiotic and post-classical approaches analyzing the properties of this narratological category, conditio... see more


Henning Bergenholtz    

Monolingual defining dictionaries often give the impression of explaining sociallyrelevant terms from a wide range of different subject fields. In practice, they includebut a fraction of the millions of terms in the various subject fields, of course. At ... see more

Revista: LexicoNordica

Hermanus C. Groenewald    

AbstractThe methodology of this article involved an examination of theoretical and empirical data so as to ascertain what the defining grammatical and semantic nature of tenses in isiZulu are with the ultimate goal of presenting an alternative view of th... see more

Revista: Literator