A Restorative Justice System in Indonesia: A Close View from the Indigenous Peoples’ Practices


The Indonesiancrime rate until May 2020 increased due to public orders and crime disturbances in the last 22 weeks.Data from correctional institutions in February 2021 showed that some regional offices were over capacity while others were normal. The 1945 IndonesianConstitution recognises traditional institutions in the criminal justice system and requires judges to consider legal values and a sense of justice in society. This study aims to determine Indonesia's customary criminal justice system as a form of restorative justice. This research used a socio-legal approach and found that public participation in Indonesia, through customary groups, can help prevent crime and solve problems through discussion and following applicable customary law processes. As a result, Indonesian researchers have regulated and recognised customary justice's existence and implemented it to deal with cases in their environment. Restorative justice is a criminal mechanism that aims to restore the relationship of the conflicting parties to the state before the conflict and is carried out informally. This concept is also an acknowledgement of oriental legal philosophy which, in resolving any conflict, always seeks to restore relations; macro stability or society can even affect the stability of the universe. The practice of Restorative Justice occurs in customary law. As a legal philosophy, the legal policy of implementing Restorative justice should be interpreted mainly as revitalising customary law if conflicts occur between fellow supporters of the same customary law. The settlement of cases in the Baduy community is straightforward. The settlement prioritises forgiving each other. Restorative justice is performed by combining criminal justice mechanisms with public participation in a discussion mediation.

 Articles related

Umar Dinata, Aksar, Saut Maruli Tua Manik    

Settlement of criminal cases with a restorative approach has begun to be applied in Indonesia, but its implementation is only related to the settlement of juvenile criminal cases. In practice, a restorative justice approach is often applied to pay more a... see more

Revista: UIR Law Review

Maiquel Ângelo Dezordi Wermuth,Rosane Teresinha Carvalho Porto,Emanuele Dallabrida Mori    

DOI: 10.1590/2179-8966/2021/57864 ResumoO artigo visa a realizar uma análise crítica do modelo penal vigente, tomando a justiça restaurativa como exemplo de outro modelo possível. Questiona-se se e em que medida ela apresenta um potencial para o ati... see more

Sulbadana Sulbadana,Haniyatul Husna binti Md Mohtar,Andi Intan Purnamasari,Supriyadi Supriyadi    

Global criminal political considerations are strengthening national laws to realise Restorative Justice for the achievement of recovery for victims, perpetrators and the social order of society. The perspective of Restorative Justice can not only be seen... see more

Hendrik Kusnianto    

The Criminal Justice System in Indonesia originates from Pancasila, because Pancasila as the source of all laws today has undergone many changes. The components that work in the criminal justice sub-system experience a rapid development which is indirect... see more

Revista: The Juris

Abdurrahman Al Akhdloriy    

Restorative justice merupakan konsep keadilan yang bertujuan untuk penyembuhan, pembelajaran moral, rasa memaafkan, tanggung jawab dan membuat perubahan yang semuanya itu merupakan pedoman bagi proses pemulihan keadilan bagi kedua pihak yang berperkara. ... see more