ARTICLE
TITLE

ACCESS OF INDIVIDUALS TO MERCOSUR TRIBUNALS: FILLING THE GAP VIA ADVISORY OPINIONS

SUMMARY

The Mercosur dispute settlement system possesses several limitations, which are linked to its transitory aspect and include, in particular, the limited access of individuals who are only able to present their demands via the National Section of the Common Market Group of the member state in question. The application of the advisory opinions’ mechanism embodies a possible alternative in order to overcome the lack of access of individuals and civil society to Mercosur Tribunals. The referred mechanism enables national courts to question the Permanent Review Court exclusively with regards to the interpretation of Mercosur law. Therefore, it guarantees an indirect access of individuals to Mercosur Tribunals. However, there is still a very low number of advisory opinions solicited to the PRC, which are due, among other factors, to the lack of knowledge of Mercosur law and its mechanisms by lawyers and national judges. This challenged is combined with a normative limitation, i.e., the double non-binding character of the advisory opinions, thereby contributing to legal uncertainty. Some alternatives have been envisaged, notably with the creation of a permanent court for Mercosur.

 Articles related

Amy Salyzyn, Lori Isaj, Brandon Piva, Jacquelyn Burkell    

We know that members of the public find court forms complex. Less is known, however, about what in particular makes these documents difficult for non-legally trained people to complete.     The study described in this article seeks to fill this informati... see more


Terry Skolnik    

This article argues that our current understanding of the relationship between access to housing and liberty (or freedom) is limited. It contends that judicial decisions and existing legal theory are predominantly concerned with the connection between ho... see more


Jennifer A Leitch    

Access to Justice remains one of the most contested issues on the law-and-society agenda.  There has been continuing conceptual debate over its meaning, its objectives, and its success.  Of late, attention has turned to efforts to measure the impact and ... see more


Margareth Vetis ZAGANELLI,João Victor Gomes CORREIA    

Objetivo: analisar a temática em relevo como uma alternativa e um direito do paciente terminal. Inicialmente, faz-se um retrospecto histórico e descreve-se as metodologias atuais da medicina paliativa, com o fito de ressaltar o enquadramento legal e as m... see more


M. Nanda Setiawan    

 The community in Batang Hari Regency exploits petroleum without a cooperation contract by drilling a well and then taking the oil contained in the well. This is one of the issues arising from oil and gas mining in Indonesia. This study aims to dete... see more