ARTICLE
TITLE

Reporting verbs argue, claim and believe in Linguistics research articles: A corpus-based study

SUMMARY

No research article is imaginable without reporting verbs. They help the writer voice his/her own views against the backdrop of other community voices, while also serving to project his/her authority and expertise in the field. The vast variety of reporting verbs in academic discourse and their disciplinary specificity account for a huge challenge this topic can pose for EAL academic writers. In this study, we analyzed the rhetorical and discursive functions of strong reporting verbs argue, claim and believe in a corpus of 40 articles from leading Linguistics journals, with close attention to their Self/Other references. It has been revealed that argue and claim are mostly used in this realm to refer to other authors, while believe is slightly more common with reference to the writer himself/herself. While it tends to be perceived as interchangeable with argue, claim is almost exclusively used to introduce the opinion of others; besides, it is often an opinion that the writer does not fully support. Also, we have shown that it is typical for argue to play a discourse-organizing role, being featured in retrospective endophoric markers. We believe it is important to help novice academic writers understand the subtle nuances in the semantics of these reporting verbs and their discourse functions.

 Articles related

Liina Tammekänd    

The paper discusses the use of present verbs in ten Estonian-Võru narrative pairs. The research questions are: which narrative tenses with which roles are used in Estonian and Võru narratives; in which narrative parts can present verbs be found; and whic... see more


Yasir Bdaiwi Jasim    

The discussion section is considered one of the most crucial sections of a research article (RA). It is challenging and problematic for both novice and native writers due to its argumentative nature. This section serves various functions such as restatin... see more


Markéta Malá, Gabriela Bruhová, Katerina Vašku    


Revista: ELOPE

Kuan-Chung Huang,Ming-Yu Tseng    

Many studies investigated metaphors in news; however, few of them focused specifically on headlines. By investigating metaphors in 133 collected NBA news headlines written in Chinese, this paper analyzes the creativity in them. Conceptual Metaphor Theory... see more


Juliana Wijaya    

The analysis of first, second and third-person reported speech in this paper reveal different uses of verbal markers and discourse practices surrounding direct reported speech in spoken Indonesian. The reporting verb and noun phrases bilang ‘to say,’ ngo... see more