ARTICLE
TITLE

Case Law as an Authoritative Source of Customary Law: Piecemeal Recording of (Living) Customary Law?

SUMMARY

This contribution deals with the question of whether a judgment from a mainstream court dealing with customary law can be regarded as authority and thus as a recording of a customary rule or rules. When a mainstream court develops customary law to promote constitutional values or strikes customary law down for want of constitutionality, it creates new rules which are written down but which can easily be changed when society brings it to court and convinces the court that the rule needs to be changed. It is my contention that case law is a binding source of law, including customary law, which must be followed until such time that it is either absorbed into legislation or amended by a subsequent decision in terms of the principle of stare decisis. It gives us some measure of assurance as to the law to be followed. The high number of customary law disputes taken to a court of law is confirmation that traditional communities are embracing the power of the courts to settle their disputes. The judgments of these courts inevitably become the origins of customary rules that they develop and can thus be regarded as piecemeal recording of (living) customary law. 

 Articles related

Ade Irma Suryani Nasution,Annisa Mutia Pranita,Desty Bulandari,Lutvia Resta Setyawati,Panji Suwarno    

Illegal fishing cases often occur in waters at the edge of Indonesia. This article is focused on examining and analyzing the synergy between the authorized institutions in the process of monitoring and handling illegal fishing cases that occur in the wat... see more


Erni Dwita Silambi, Rosnida Rosnida, Enni Eka kusumawati    

The provision of customary criminal sanctions varies according to the customs and norms that apply in an area and this research takes a case study in Merauke Papua. This research focuses on the provision of customary sanctions for perpetrators which will... see more


Kuntadi Kuntadi 10.20884/1.jdh.2022.22.2.3242    

House of Restorative Justice is a follow-up to the existence of the Prosecutor’s Regulation of the Republic of Indonesia Number 15 of 2020 concerning the Termination of Prosecution Based on Restorative Justice. The establishment of this house aims to be ... see more


Dasrol Dasrol,Evi Deliana HZ    

Kubu Regency is one of the areas in Riau Province that still applies the settlement of legal cases using customary law, which involves the role of Ninik Mamak and traditional leaders, especially as mediators. This study aimed to know the position of Nini... see more


Aziz Tuffi Saliba,Lucas Carlos Lima    

It was 1943 when the Changri-La fishing boat and its ten fishermen crew disappeared near Cabo Frio, Rio de Janeiro. But only in 2001 the Tribunal Marítimo da Marinha do Brasil recognized that the vessel had been sunk by a German submarine. The relatives... see more