ARTICLE
TITLE

MODELS FOR CALCULATING WEIGHTS FOR ESTIMATION INNOVATIVE TECHNICAL OBJECTS

SUMMARY

Relevance. The relevance of the work is associated with a multi-criteria comparison of innovative objects, which are understood as objects with partially identical individual indicators that have uncertain, subjective values and criteria for their evaluation. Compared innovation objects are described by General and individual indicators, and the number of individual indicators is significant (more than 50%). The hierarchy analysis method is the most suitable mathematical tool for comparing innovative objects, since it combines visual description of the subject area, numerical performance, and natural accounting for the variability of the initial pair estimates. However, this method does not take into account the individual indicators of innovative objects when compiling matrices of paired comparisons, which does not allow you to get the final weights corresponding to the individual characteristics of innovative objects.Object. Development of a modified hierarchy analysis method that provides ranking of innovative objects with partially identical individual indicators.Method. In this work, a modified method of analysis of hierarchies, comprising a typical sequence of stages from building a hierarchy of the subject area and the establishment of criteria for evaluation of innovative objects to the stage computing the final weights of innovative objects, a first introduction on the stage of building a hierarchy of the weights matrix shared and individual performance in the system of objects, and secondly by calculating correction factors based on local or global models of correction of weights of parameters of systems of objects at the stage of preparation of the consolidated table of weights, thirdly the computation of the final weights of innovative features based on a correction factor that took into account individual features compare innovative.Results. The paper considers innovative objects with General and individual indicators in the ratio of 1:2 with the number of comparison criteria equal to 5, which corresponds to the class of objects of average organizational complexity. The objects being compared contain a typical object (the number of individual indicators is significantly less than 50%), a clearly innovative object (the number of individual indicators is more than 50%), and an object in the border zone (the number of individual indicators is about 50%). The classical method is not sensitive to the individual characteristics of innovative objects, which determined the minimum weight for a clearly innovative object. The modified method, on the contrary, determined the minimum weight for the object in the border zone, since it has both reduced values in the matrix of paired comparisons by criteria and low values of individual indicators.Conclusions. The developed modified method of hierarchy analysis and correction models in its composition objectively reflect the order of ranking of objects, taking into account their description in the form of a matrix of General and individual indicators. According to the modeling, the share of individual indicators in their total number of more than 55% should be considered valuable for decision-making practice. In this case, it is preferable to evaluate objects based on a modified hierarchy analysis method. The vector of correction coefficients obtained on the basis of the weight correction model has an independent value in solving various computational and analytical problems and applied decision-making problems.

 Articles related

Angelica Amartya Putri,Herlina Jayadianti,Bambang Yuwono    

Purpose: This study aims to measure success and determine the factors that support or hinder the success of the Jogja Istimewa application.Methodology: This study uses a modified DeLone and McLean Model 2003. The data used are primary data obtained from ... see more

Revista: Telematika

Desti Mualfah, Rizdqi Akbar Ramadhan    

Kejahatan konvensial yang terekam kamera CCTV (Closed Circuit Televison) semakin banyak ditemukan di masyarakat, setiap pelaku kejahatan yang terbukti melakukan tindak pidana tertentu akan dihukum sesuai dengan peraturan perundang-undangan. Kamera CCTV m... see more


Annida Purnamawati,Wawan Nugroho,Destiana Putri,Wahyutama Fitri Hidayat    

Pertanian sebagai salah satu sektor industri menjadi bagian pekerjaan yang menunjang pemenuhan kebutuhan makanan pokok masyarakat seperti tanaman pangan. Tanaman padi merupakan tanaman pangan yang rentan terserang hama. Pengenalan terhadap jenis hama yan... see more


E. V. Ivohin,L. T. Adzhubey,O. V. Gavrylenko,Yu. O. Naumenko    

Context. Solving of the problem of formalization and study of the development of the process of information dissemination over time and its impact on the society is very important for ensuring information security. It is necessary to use a fundamentally ... see more


N. M. Lutska,A. P. Ladanyuk,T. V. Savchenko    

Context. The problem of identification of the mathematical models of the technological objects on the basis of which the robustcontrol system is subsequently synthesized has been considered. The methods of identification of the mathematical models of the... see more