ARTICLE
TITLE

A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF CONVENTIONAL AND SHARIAH LIFE INSURANCE EFFICIENCY USING DATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYSIS10.22373/share.v9i2.7595

SUMMARY

This study aims to analyze and compare the efficiency between conventional life insurance companies and Islamic life insurance companies in Indonesia over the period of 2014-2018. The sample of this study was taken from 10 conventional life insurance companies and 10 shariah life insurance companies that were selected based on the purposive sampling technique. Measurement of efficiency in this study was conducted using the method of data envelopment analysis (DEA) based on Bankers-Charnes-Cooper (BCC) and Charnes-Cooper-Rhodes (CCR) models of the value-added approach. This was followed by testing the hypothesis using a different Mann-Whitney U-test. Input variables used are assets, capital, general and administrative costs, and commission expenses. Meanwhile, the output variables are premiums and investment income. The results showed that conventional life insurance companies are more efficient than Islamic life insurance companies based on the BCC and CCR models. Furthermore, the results of different tests using the Mann-Whitney U-test showed an insignificant difference in efficiency between conventional life insurance companies and Islamic life insurance companies during the study period. The results of the comparison of the average efficiency value with the DEA method indicated that the efficiency level of a conventional life insurance company was better than a shariah life insurance company.========================================================================================================

 Articles related

Dewi Rekno Ulansari,Dina Fitrisia Septiarini    

This study aimed to analyze the value of efficiency and the comparison of efficiency ratio in conventional insurance companies and Islamic Sharia Business Unit (ISBU) of Sharia insurance, both life and general insurance, in Indonesia from 2011-2018. The ... see more


Choong Ho Shin, Hyejin Cho, Myeong Hyeon Cho    

A chaebol is a Korean business group with a unique organizational structure in which both ownership and control rights held by a family. As their production accounts for nearly fifty percent of Korea’s GDP and their power in the labor market, it is impor... see more


Rosilene Marcon,Everson Manoel de Souza    

This study had the objective to investigate the economical and of market performance of the Brazilian companies before and after the inclusion in the levels of corporate governance proposed by BOVESPA. The study period understood the years from 1999 to 2... see more



This article analyzes the evolution of the theoretical concept and the practices that involve the Human Security in the world context, and subsequently, with an emphasis on Brazil. It brings a comparative study between the Foreign Statute(... see more


Morten Kousgaard Larsen, Jacob Lange Nissen, Rainer Lueg, Christian Schmaltz, Joachim Rojkjaer Thorhauge    

The Danish Banking sector faces increasing requirements regarding regulation and profitability, which especially threatens small and medium sized banks. This study analyzes whether the successful business model of Handelsbanken (The Handelsbanken Way) ca... see more