ARTICLE
TITLE

THE METHOD OF ALTERNATIVE RANKING FOR A COLLECTIVE EXPERT ESTIMATION PROCEDURE

SUMMARY

Context. The actual problem of constructing a mathematical model of a collective multi-criteria expert estimation of alternatives, which is an integral part of the automation of the intellectual decision-making process, has been solved. Objective. The goal of the work is to develop a method for determining relative collective multi-criteria estimation of alternatives and their subsequent ranking based on information about personal preferences of experts. The object of research is the process of analysis and decision-making in multi-criteria conditions. The subject of the research are the methods of structural and parametric identification of the model of multi-criteria estimation of alternatives.Method. The paper proposes an approach to constructing a model of collective multi-criteria estimation of alternatives based on information about partial-order relationships established by experts on the set of available alternatives. A method for structural and parametric identification of a model of multi-criteria estimation, which based on the ideas of the theory of comparator identification is proposed. It is shown that the solution to the problem of choosing the structure of a model of optimal complexity should be carried out in the class of Kolmogorov-Gabors polynomial. To find the parameters of the estimation model, it is proposed to use a method that is based on the calculating of the Chebyshev point. It is shown that in this case, the parametric identification problem of the model can be reduced to the standard linear programming problem. The scalar collective multi-criteria estimates of alternatives obtained on the basis of the synthesized mathematical model make it possible to compare them with each other in terms of “quality” and, thus, select the “best” of them or rank them.Results. An approach has been developed to construct a mathematical model of collective multi-criteria expert estimation, on the basis of which it is possible to determine group generalized estimates of alternatives, as well as to rank them. The results of simulation modeling, which demonstrate the practical feasibility and effectiveness of the proposed approach are presented.Conclusions. A significant advantage of the approach is the ability to use only non-numerical information about the preferences of experts. This allows you to partially solve the problem of subjectivity of expert opinions in the process of decision-making and reduce the cost of a collective expert estimation of alternatives. The synthesized model of collective expert estimation can serve as the basis for solving the problems of estimating the quality of various projects, investment management, strategic planning, and the development of problem-oriented decision support systems. In the future, it is worth considering the possibility of supplementing the presented approach with the possibility of taking into account estimates of the qualitative composition and competence of individual experts, which are included in the group. 

 Articles related

Sugiarto Sugiarto,. Lulusi,Sofyan M. Saleh    

The term of capacity is very useful to quantify the ability of transport facilities in terms of carrying traffic. The capacity of the road is an essential ingredient in the planning, design, and operation of roadways. It is desirable for traffic analyst ... see more


Laina Hilma Sari,Zulfian .    

Abstract - Thermal comfort calculated using ISO 7730 has been questioned and responded by more adaptive thermal comfort methods. This study was therefore conducted to assess the acceptable thermal comfort for the local people in the tropical Aceh using t... see more


Ichwana -,Zulkifli Nasution,Sumono -    

Abstract - Volume of groundwater recharge showed a picture of a watershed to determine the flow instability due to the physical characteristics of the watershed and precipitation. Many methods had been constructed to understand the dynamic movement ... see more


Mala Rosa Aprillya, Uswatun Chasanah    

East Java has various regional conditions. The condition of the area certainly has the potential for disasters that have a significant impact on the agricultural sector. Flood is one of the factors that damage agricultural land. Flood risk management pla... see more


Irvan Denata,Tedy Rismawan,Ikhwan Ruslianto    

Orange is a type of fruit that is easily found in Sambas Regency. The types that are widely sold are Siam oranges, madu susu and susu. Each type of orange has a different quality and a different price. The price difference often results in fraud committe... see more

Revista: Telematika