ARTICLE
TITLE

Declarative System in Preventing the Criminalisation of Indigenous People for Adat Rights Conflicts in Indonesia

SUMMARY

The existence of indigenous peoples as entities was born before the independence of the Republic of Indonesia. However, it is still disturbed by criminalisation by law enforcement officials for legal actions of indigenous peoples on their Adat lands whose Adat rights were transferred to other parties. Various regulations related to indigenous peoples already exist, and the Bill on Indigenous Peoples is not satisfying in preventing cases of criminalisation against indigenous peoples. It is because there is no adjustment in several crucial aspects, such as the nature of the recognition of indigenous people, protection of Adat lands and the application of criminal sanctions to achieve legal harmonisation in preventing the criminalisation of indigenous peoples. Synchronisation has not yet been realised between the substance of the legal rules related to indigenous peoples at the national level and the draft Bill on Indigenous Peoples with regional technical regulations at the sectoral level.This research uses statute and conceptual approaches to analyse legal norms, legal concepts, and legal principles related to indigenous people in Indonesia. As a result, it is believed that the protection of indigenous people's existence should be provided through a declarative system, not a constitutive system. It is also necessary to eliminate criminal sanctions against indigenous peoples in some related legal products according to the characteristics of indigenous peoples to stop the criminalisation of indigenous peoples and expand legal assistance for indigenous peoples in the context of implementing the law.

 Articles related

Laura Fernanda Melo Nascimento,Caroline Barbosa Contente Nogueira    

DOI: 10.1590/2179-8966/2021/50145Resumo O presente artigo demonstra como o procedimento de consulta aos povos indígenas torna-se um mecanismo de participação democrática quando minorado o desequilíbrio de poder simbólico e adotado&nbs... see more


Andre Augusto Salvador Bezerra    

DOI: 10.1590/2179-8966/2021/50348Resumo O artigo objetiva apontar que, dentre os fatores de violações aos direitos dos indígenas, está uma incompreensão, por membros dos tribunais, das ontologia... see more


Milena Petters MELO,Thiago BURCKHART    

Objectives: Taking in consideration the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on Brazilian law, the aim of this article is to analyze the legal measures adopted by the Brazilian State in order to safeguard indigenous peoples in Brazilian Amazon, focusing on th... see more


Miguel Gualano de Godoy,Carolina Ribeiro Santana,Lucas Cravo de Oliveira    

DOI: 10.1590/2179-8966/2021/61730ResumoEsta pesquisa analisa a Arguição de Descumprimento de Preceito Fundamental (ADPF) 709, proposta no Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF), no que tange à proteção ao direito à saúde dos povos indígenas isolados e de recente... see more


Valentina de GREGORIO,Giulia PAROLA,Arianna PORRONE,Margherita Paola POTO,Apostolos TSIOUVALAS    

ABSTRACTObjective: The paper analyses the deep contributions of Indigenous knowledge on enriching and encouraging change to laws and research and training the Western legal systems to listen to other voices that have been silenced for centuries.Methodolo... see more