Home  /  Entropy  /  Vol: 21 Núm: 1 Par: January (2019)  /  Article
ARTICLE
TITLE

Uncertainty Assessment of Hyperspectral Image Classification: Deep Learning vs. Random Forest

SUMMARY

Uncertainty assessment techniques have been extensively applied as an estimate of accuracy to compensate for weaknesses with traditional approaches. Traditional approaches to mapping accuracy assessment have been based on a confusion matrix, and hence are not only dependent on the availability of test data but also incapable of capturing the spatial variation in classification error. Here, we apply and compare two uncertainty assessment techniques that do not rely on test data availability and enable the spatial characterisation of classification accuracy before the validation phase, promoting the assessment of error propagation within the classified imagery products. We compared the performance of emerging deep neural network (DNN) with the popular random forest (RF) technique. Uncertainty assessment was implemented by calculating the Shannon entropy of class probabilities predicted by DNN and RF for every pixel. The classification uncertainties of DNN and RF were quantified for two different hyperspectral image datasets—Salinas and Indian Pines. We then compared the uncertainty against the classification accuracy of the techniques represented by a modified root mean square error (RMSE). The results indicate that considering modified RMSE values for various sample sizes of both datasets, the derived entropy based on the DNN algorithm is a better estimate of classification accuracy and hence provides a superior uncertainty estimate at the pixel level.

 Articles related

Kenric P. Nelson    

An approach to the assessment of probabilistic inference is described which quantifies the performance on the probability scale. From both information and Bayesian theory, the central tendency of an inference is proven to be the geometric mean of the pro... see more

Revista: Entropy

Sandra Hamel, Nigel Gilles Yoccoz    

Evidence from most studies is based on a black and white requirement of statistical significance, completely neglecting the uncertainty. This deterministic thinking is problematic because statistical significance on its own tells nothing about the magnit... see more


Adrian M. Tompkins, Luca Caporaso    

Using mathematical modelling tools, we assessed the potential for land use change (LUC) associated with the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change low- and high-end emission scenarios (RCP2.6 and RCP8.5) to impact malaria transmission in Africa. To dr... see more



The most relevant SESAR 2020 solutions dealing with future Capacity Management processes are Dynamic Airspace Configuration (DAC) and Flight Centric ATC (FCA). Both concepts, DAC and FCA, rely on traffic flow complexity assessment. For this reason, compl... see more

Revista: Energies

Zhiqi Yang, Jinwei Dong, Jiyuan Liu, Jun Zhai, Wenhui Kuang, Guosong Zhao, Wei Shen, Yan Zhou, Yuanwei Qin and And Xiangming Xiao    

Forests play an important role in maintaining ecosystem services, especially in ecologically fragile areas such as the Loess Plateau (LP) in China. However, there is still great uncertainty in the spatial extent and distribution of forests in such a frag... see more